List of Top 10 Columbus Personal Injury Lawyers

We found the best Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus, Ohio.

We found the best Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus, Ohio.


Kisling, Nestico & Redick

Kisling, Nestico & Redick (KNR) is one of Ohio’s largest personal injury law firms, founded in 2005 by three attorneys with a vision to help injury victims get maximum compensation from insurance companies. With over 35 lawyers and nearly 100 support staff across 12 offices, KNR has recovered millions for clients through their extensive courtroom experience and commitment to preparing every case for trial.

Pros: The reviews overwhelmingly praise Kisling, Nestico & Redick (KNR) for their exceptional communication, caring and dedicated attorneys, and successful resolution of cases that often exceed client expectations. Clients laud the firm’s professionalism, responsiveness to questions, and commitment to achieving favorable outcomes.

Cons: A few reviewers noted instances where communication and follow-up fell short of KNR’s typical high standards.


Feature Your Columbus Business

Premium placement is available for this sector. Contact our team for more details.

Schiff & Associates Co., LPA

For over 40 years, the attorneys at Schiff & Associates in Columbus, Ohio have provided trusted legal representation in personal injury and wrongful death cases. With a team of lawyers focused on both litigation and settlements, along with support staff including investigators and legal assistants, the firm is dedicated to helping clients receive full compensation through thorough case analysis and preparation.

Pros: Schiff & Associates Co., LPA stands out for its professionalism, responsiveness, and caring approach, consistently praised by clients for effective representation that secured fair outcomes and seamless guidance through challenging personal injury cases. The firm’s paralegals and case managers earned accolades for their attentiveness, prompt communication, and dedication to making clients feel prioritized.

Cons: A few reviewers felt their smaller cases lacked sufficient attention.

The Fitch Law Firm

The Fitch Law Firm, an experienced Columbus personal injury law office, provides aggressive representation to protect clients’ rights when dealing with insurance companies after an injury. With over 30 years of experience practicing Ohio law, the firm takes cases on a contingency fee basis and is dedicated to achieving successful outcomes through thorough legal knowledge and a commitment to seeking justice for victims.

Pros: The Fitch Law Firm shines through its excellent client communication, keeping clients consistently informed and promptly addressing concerns with clear explanations. Reviewers commend the firm’s professionalism, tireless advocacy, and compassionate, personalized service that makes clients feel truly valued. The attorneys are praised for their dedication, fighting tenaciously to secure favorable outcomes.

Cons: A few reviews mention cases taking longer than expected to resolve.

Erney Law

Robert D. Erney is a highly experienced and accomplished attorney who has been practicing law in Ohio since 1986. After graduating from Ohio Dominican College and the University of Cincinnati College of Law, he went on to serve as a judicial clerk and gain admittance to several prestigious bars, including the U.S. Supreme Court. Erney is an active member of many legal associations, has served in leadership roles, published extensively, and is heavily involved in the community.

Pros: The reviews overwhelmingly highlight the professionalism, outstanding legal expertise, and compassionate approach of Robert Erney, Mary Erney, and their team, with clients praising their responsiveness, effective communication, and dedication to achieving the best possible outcomes. Clients felt well-informed throughout the process and appreciated the personal attention they received, even in complex cases.

Cons: The lack of explicitly negative reviews suggests potential clients may benefit from seeking additional perspectives to make a fully informed decision.

The Donahey Law Firm

The Donahey Law Firm, one of Ohio’s most respected personal injury law firms since 1968, provides skilled representation and personalized service to help injury victims obtain full and fair compensation. With a proven track record including many multi-million dollar recoveries, their experienced Columbus personal injury attorneys aggressively pursue maximum damages for clients in cases ranging from auto accidents to medical malpractice, taking on insurance companies and working on a contingency fee basis.

Pros: The Donahey Law Firm’s attorneys are widely praised for their professionalism, legal expertise, and compassionate approach that makes clients feel truly valued. Reviewers commend the firm’s excellent communication, keeping clients well-informed throughout the legal process, and its dedication to achieving favorable outcomes. A caring, client-focused mindset is consistently highlighted as a strength.

Cons: Negative reviews mention isolated instances of poor communication and lack of responsiveness.

GB Law

For over 25 years, GB Law has been the preeminent Columbus area injury law firm, representing thousands of clients and recovering over $200 million while protecting Ohioans and their families from corporate and insurance company abuses. With a focus on superior service and results, the firm’s lawyers live locally and relentlessly pursue cases, working on a contingency basis and partnering with other attorneys on major injury cases through co-counsel agreements.

Pros: Clients rave about GB Law’s excellent communication, with attorneys praised for keeping them well-informed and promptly addressing questions throughout their cases. The firm’s professionalism, expertise, and genuine compassion shine through, as numerous reviews highlight their success in securing favorable outcomes and fair settlements for injured clients. Positive sentiments abound, commending the attentive service and tenacious representation provided by the GB Law team.

Cons: Some reviewers expressed concerns over the handling of their specific cases.

Amourgis & Associates

Founded in 1999 by Dino Colombo in Morgantown, West Virginia, Colombo Law started as a small firm dedicated to helping personal injury victims restore their quality of life after accidents. Over time, the firm has grown to include seasoned attorneys with over 40 years of combined experience across offices in West Virginia and Ohio, offering a “No Fee Promise” and the “Colombo Advantage” of experienced representation against insurance companies as well as community outreach programs.

Pros: Colombo Law garners widespread praise for its exceptional client communication, keeping clients well-informed throughout the legal process with responsiveness and professionalism. Clients laud the firm’s high-quality legal representation, diligent efforts to secure favorable outcomes, and caring, compassionate approach that makes them feel valued.

Cons: One reviewer noted an instance of delayed response time, leading the client to seek representation elsewhere.

Amourgis & Associates

Amourgis & Associates is a consumer-focused law firm that exclusively represents individuals who have been injured in accidents or need debt relief solutions. Their attorneys take a personalized approach, working quickly to understand each client’s unique situation and craft tailored strategies to fight for their rights and secure the best possible outcome.

Pros: Amourgis & Associates receives widespread praise for their attorneys’ professionalism, depth of knowledge, and ability to provide personalized attention while guiding clients through complex legal matters. Clients laud the responsiveness of the team, their skill in clearly explaining processes, and their compassionate approach to understanding unique situations. The firm garners commendations for making clients feel at ease and delivering thorough, high-quality service.

Cons: One area of concern expressed in some reviews is a lack of follow-through and communication lapses after the initial stages.

Malek & Malek Law Firm

The Malek & Malek Law Firm has been serving Columbus, Ohio and surrounding areas since 1972, founded by Ed Malek and now including three of his sons as attorneys, combining for over 60 years of experience. As a family-run firm concentrating exclusively on protecting the rights of accident victims, injured parties and their families, their attorneys provide zealous advocacy across personal injury cases from workers’ compensation to auto accidents while also giving back through pro bono work and volunteering in the local community.

Pros: The reviews overwhelmingly praise Malek & Malek Law Firm for their professionalism, expertise in handling personal injury and workers’ compensation cases, and their client-focused approach that makes clients feel like family. Clients laud the firm’s responsiveness, clear communication, and unwavering commitment to protecting their interests and securing favorable outcomes.

Cons: A few reviews indicate that the firm’s scope being limited primarily to personal injury and workers’ compensation matters means they may not take cases relating to wrongful termination or employment law.