List of Top Columbus Home Builders

We found the best Home Builders in Columbus, Ohio.

We determined the top home builders in Columbus so you can find the right home builder for your needs.


Romanelli & Hughes

Romanelli and Hughes, a premier custom luxury home builder in Central Ohio, has been synonymous with excellence and craftsmanship for nearly 50 years. With a talented team of designers, architects, and energy-efficiency experts, they offer multi-level services to simplify the homebuilding experience and deliver stunning, unique, and energy-efficient homes. Their commitment to quality materials, expert craftsmanship, and unwavering attention to detail results in solid, timeless homes that only get better with age.

Pros: Romanelli & Hughes garners praise for their top-notch craftsmanship, exceptional customer service, and streamlined design and building process that alleviates stress for homebuyers. Reviewers laud the quality construction down to the smallest details, the responsiveness and professionalism of the team, and the convenience of selecting finishes in their design studio.
Cons: One reviewer noted a difficult time with the company.


Feature Your Columbus Business

Premium placement is available for this sector. Contact our team for more details.

M/I Homes

M/I Homes, founded in 1976 by cousins Melvin and Irving Schottenstein, has grown to become Central Ohio’s leading homebuilder. The company prides itself on its exclusive building standards, energy-efficient homes, design services, and comprehensive warranty packages, ensuring high-quality construction and customer satisfaction. M/I Homes also offers financing services to streamline the home-buying process for its clients.

Pros: M/I Homes receives praise for their professional and knowledgeable staff who guide customers through the home buying and building process. Customers frequently laud the quality construction and ability to customize their dream homes through the company’s impressive design center.
Cons: The negative reviews highlight occasional customer service issues.

Trinity Homes

Trinity Homes is a premier Central Ohio homebuilder with over 50 years of experience, known for its commitment to quality craftsmanship, energy-efficient materials, and personalized home designs tailored to each customer’s lifestyle and vision. The company’s attention to detail, use of high-quality materials, and dedication to customer satisfaction set it apart, exemplified by its 35-year transferable structural home warranty. Trinity Homes strives to create unique homes that not only meet but exceed customers’ expectations.

Pros: Trinity Homes seems to build quality homes with nice layouts and floor plans that allow for customization to suit individual needs. Multiple reviewers praised the professionalism of the company’s staff throughout the home-building experience. Customers appreciate the opportunity to make their dream home truly their own through Trinity’s allowance of customizations.
Cons: Significant delays in the construction process and a lack of communication regarding timeline changes appear to be major issues based on negative reviews.

Rockford Homes

Rockford Homes, founded in 1985 by Robert E. Yoakam Sr., is Central Ohio’s largest privately held homebuilder with over 35 years of experience providing quality construction, competitive pricing, and exceptional customer service. The company’s core philosophy revolves around building quality homes in prime locations while remaining responsive to customer needs and feedback. Rockford Homes’ commitment to customer satisfaction is evident throughout the home-buying process, from personalized design consultations to long-lasting warranties, earning them recognition as BIA Builder of the Year in 2002 and 2016.

Pros: Rockford Homes shines with its exceptional build quality, attention to detail, and professional customer service, as evident from numerous reviews praising their high-quality craftsmanship, responsive staff, and ability to accommodate customization preferences. Customers appreciate the company’s willingness to listen and work closely with them to create their dream homes.
Cons: Delays in construction timelines and poor communication regarding these delays have been a source of frustration expressed by some reviewers.

Diyanni Homes

Diyanni Homes was founded in 1979 by the Diyanni family, whose core values of honesty, integrity, and respect – instilled by their father – remain at the heart of the company today. Over the past four decades, Diyanni Homes has built over 2,500 homes in Ohio, earning numerous awards including several consecutive BIA Parade of Homes People’s Choice Awards for their innovative and high-quality craftsmanship. With a focus on custom home building in recent years, Diyanni Homes continues to prioritize customer satisfaction through their hands-on approach and commitment to Biblical principles.

Pros: Diyanni Homes garners ample praise for their knowledgeable and friendly staff who effectively guide homebuyers through the design and selection process, their responsiveness in addressing questions promptly, and the remarkable quality exhibited in their solidly built homes replete with premium features often considered upgrades elsewhere.
Cons: The negative reviews bemoan instances of extended delays and significantly protracted build times beyond initial estimates.

Bob Webb Homes

Bob Webb Custom Homes is a family-owned business that has been Central Ohio’s #1 luxury home builder for over 60 years. Founded on the principles of quality craftsmanship, innovation, and building true custom homes tailored to each client’s vision, the company guides customers through every step of the process – from design to construction to personalized finishing touches. Bob Webb’s experienced team and commitment to creating unique living spaces has earned them a reputation as a trusted partner for luxury homebuyers.

Pros: Glowing reviews praise Bob Webb Homes for their exceptional quality craftsmanship, personalized design options, and outstanding customer service that keeps clients informed every step of the way. Clients rave about the company’s professionalism, attention to detail, and ability to bring their dream homes to life.
Cons: Negative feedback highlights the disruptive noise levels and early start times from contractors that disturbed existing neighborhoods during construction.

Nicholson Builders

Nicholson Builders is a design-build firm with a comprehensive in-house team covering all aspects of remodeling projects. Their staff includes owners, executive leadership, design consultants, interior designers, architects, office administration, production managers, project managers, carpenters, tile specialists, a small projects division, and a commercial division. With experts in various disciplines, Nicholson Builders provides clients with end-to-end service and personalized guidance throughout the entire remodeling process.

Pros: Nicholson Builders excels in delivering exceptional craftsmanship with remarkable attention to detail, earning high praise for their professionalism, responsiveness, and ability to tackle projects of any scale. Customers rave about the company’s commitment to quality workmanship, clear communication, and talent for transforming spaces into stunning realities that exceed expectations. Their team’s friendliness and skill in addressing concerns throughout the process contribute to an overwhelmingly positive experience.
Cons: Potential clients may face longer lead times due to high demand for their services.

D.R. Horton Columbus

D.R. Horton is America’s largest homebuilder, having delivered over 1 million homes since its founding in 1978. With a mission focused on quality and affordability, the company offers a seamless experience through its integrated mortgage, title, and insurance services. D.R. Horton builds homes for every stage of life across the country and provides options for both home purchases and rentals, catering to a wide range of customers.

Pros: D.R. Horton Columbus shines through its knowledgeable and responsive sales representatives who guide clients seamlessly throughout the home-buying journey, offering quality homes at great value, particularly during challenging times like the pandemic. Real estate agents rave about the excellent service and support provided, making D.R. Horton a top choice for new construction purchases.
Cons: Negative reviews highlight poor follow-up and lack of responsiveness in addressing warranty issues or construction defects after closing.

American Heritage Homes

American Heritage Homes was founded in 1995 by Bill Crum and Gary Libertini, combining Crum’s expertise in construction management with Libertini’s architectural design skills to build custom homes tailored to each customer’s lifestyle. Despite its national-sounding name, the company takes pride in being a local, hands-on builder in Columbus, Ohio, with the founders personally involved in daily operations. American Heritage Homes has received numerous accolades, including awards from the Central Ohio BIA Parade of Homes, recognitions as a Best Place to Work, and an Entrepreneur of the Year acknowledgment.

Pros: American Heritage Homes garners widespread praise for their quality construction, exceptional customer service, and ability to make the home-building process stress-free, with many customers lauding the friendly staff, transparency, and the company’s willingness to accommodate modifications. Numerous reviews commend the end result, describing homes that turned out exactly as envisioned without major issues even years later.
Cons: Poor communication and lack of attention to detail when juggling multiple projects was a point of criticism.

Schumacher Homes of Columbus North, OH

Schumacher Homes has spent over 30 years perfecting a unique and transparent process to guide customers through building their dream custom home, from the initial design phase to construction and final move-in. With a commitment to making the home-building experience enjoyable and hassle-free, Schumacher provides dedicated specialists, design studios, model homes, and a detailed build process backed by over 20,000 homes constructed and recognition like the National Housing Quality Award. The company aims to make custom homes attainable for all through its expertise and customer-centric approach.

Pros: Schumacher Homes excels in delivering high-quality, customized homes through its talented team of project managers who prioritize clear communication, responsiveness, and attention to detail throughout the build process. Homeowners rave about the professionalism, craftmanship, and ability to bring their visions to life. The design consultants also receive praise for their expertise in personalizing layouts and selections.
Cons: Negative reviews mention inconsistencies with subcontractors and after-sales support lacking at times.