List of Top 10 Columbus Criminal Lawyers

We found the best Criminal Attorneys in Columbus, Ohio.

We determined the top criminal lawyers in Columbus so you can find the right attorney for your legal needs.


Joslyn Law Firm

Joslyn Law Firm has successfully handled over 15,000 cases. Their talented legal team of hardworking and compassionate attorneys and paralegals upholds the standard of being legal leaders in criminal and DUI/OVI defense, recognized by respected legal organizations both nationally and locally.

Pros: The reviews overwhelmingly praise Joslyn Law Firm’s excellent legal representation, with many clients expressing gratitude for the attorneys’ expertise in achieving favorable outcomes like reduced or dismissed charges. Clients consistently laud the firm’s responsiveness, clear communication, compassionate service, and ability to instill confidence during stressful legal situations. The professionalism, trustworthiness, and dedication of attorneys are frequently highlighted.

Cons: A few isolated reviews mention issues with communication breakdowns or lack of staff coordination.


Feature Your Columbus Business

Premium placement is available for this sector. Contact our team for more details.

Brandon Shroy, Criminal Defense Attorney

Brandon Shroy, a former Franklin County Prosecuting Attorney, has been a respected Columbus criminal defense attorney since 2006, focusing solely on criminal and traffic cases in Ohio and federal courts. Named a “Best Lawyer” in criminal defense by Columbus CEO magazine in 2022 and 2023, Shroy is a member of the Columbus Bar Association, Ohio State Bar Association, and Federal Bar Association, and has been consulted by law enforcement as a trusted legal resource.

Pros: Brandon Shroy’s criminal defense law firm is widely praised for its professionalism, legal expertise, and ability to achieve positive outcomes for clients. Reviewers commend Shroy’s clear communication, attentiveness to clients’ needs, and genuine concern for their well-being throughout the legal process. Clients express confidence in Shroy’s mastery of the law and his skill in navigating complex cases effectively.

Cons: One review claimed lack of responsiveness and dissatisfaction with the service provided.

Luftman, Heck & Associates LLP

Luftman, Heck & Associates (LHA) is a Columbus-based criminal defense law firm led by experienced attorney Benjamin L. Luftman. The team at LHA has successfully represented thousands of clients facing various criminal charges, ranging from serious felonies to minor traffic offenses, with a focus on OVI and DUI cases.

Pros: The reviews overwhelmingly laud Luftman, Heck & Associates LLP for their exceptional responsiveness, keeping clients thoroughly informed throughout their cases, skilled legal expertise resulting in favorable outcomes, and affordable pricing offering great value. They are praised as a highly professional, knowledgeable, and communicative team dedicated to client satisfaction.

Cons: One reviewer expressed dissatisfaction, claiming a lack of responsiveness over a 6-month period.

Probst Law Office, Inc

Michael S. Probst is an experienced Columbus-based attorney specializing in criminal defense, DUI/OVI cases, and traffic offenses. With nearly two decades of expertise, including prosecutorial experience and extensive courtroom knowledge, Probst provides aggressive representation and has secured favorable outcomes for numerous clients facing criminal charges.

Pros: Probst Law Office, Inc. is widely praised for Michael Probst’s professionalism, extensive legal expertise, exceptional communication, and dedicated personal approach that goes the extra mile for clients. Reviewers commend his responsiveness, attentiveness to detail, ability to achieve favorable outcomes, and client-centric service that values their worth.

Cons: One negative review alleges feeling they were overbilled.

Rutan Law

The Rutan Law Firm, founded by attorney John Philip Milton Rutan, provides robust criminal defense representation to clients in Columbus, Franklin County, and throughout Ohio. With experience from the public defender’s office and a mission to explore every legal avenue, the firm offers personalized attention and excellence in defending against charges ranging from DUI/OMVI to serious felonies.

Pros: John Rutan is widely praised for his exceptional legal expertise, unwavering dedication to clients, and stellar communication skills that leave clients feeling informed and supported throughout their cases. Numerous reviews applaud his ability to secure favorable outcomes, even in seemingly hopeless situations, through his tireless efforts and strategic approach. Rutan’s responsiveness, professionalism, and genuine care for his clients’ wellbeing are consistently highlighted as notable strengths.

Cons: One dissatisfied reviewer criticized Rutan’s handling of their case, alleging unfavorable results at trial.

W. Joseph Edwards Attorney At Law

W. Joseph Edwards is a highly experienced Columbus criminal defense attorney who began his career as a prosecutor before establishing his own practice in 1990. With over 100 felony jury trials, numerous appeals, and expertise spanning from DUI to complex fraud cases, Edwards leverages his unique perspective from both sides to provide clients with exceptional legal representation across central Ohio and federal courts.

Pros: W. Joseph Edwards Attorney At Law is widely praised for Mr. Edwards’ professionalism, extensive legal knowledge, and fierce advocacy for his clients in the courtroom. Clients laud his responsiveness, accessibility, and dedication to achieving the best possible outcomes. Many reviews highlight his commendable work ethic, ethical standards, and ability to provide valuable guidance throughout their cases.

Cons: A few clients have expressed dissatisfaction with communication issues or unfulfilled promises.

Blake Law Firm

Dustin Blake is a premier criminal defense attorney, representing individuals and professionals charged with felonies, misdemeanors, DUI/OVI, and various other crimes. With a track record of achieving superior results through strategic case evaluation, investigation utilizing expert resources, and an ability to secure not-guilty verdicts at trial when needed, Blake provides clients with exceptional legal representation backed by numerous accolades and bar admissions.

Pros: Based on the reviews, Blake Law Firm stands out for Dustin Blake’s unparalleled professionalism, legal expertise, and unwavering dedication to achieving favorable outcomes for his clients. Clients consistently praise his responsiveness, persistence, and commitment to prioritizing their best interests throughout the legal process. The firm’s track record of success is further bolstered by Blake’s well-rounded knowledge and ability to navigate complex cases skillfully.

Cons: Costs for the firm’s services are noted to be higher than some competitors.

Law Office of James D. Owen, LLC

James D. Owen is a renowned Columbus attorney with an exceptional track record in winning challenging criminal cases, including multiple high-profile death penalty murder acquittals and post-conviction exonerations. Through meticulous investigation, unearthing new evidence, and tenacious litigation over decades, Owen has successfully overturned wrongful convictions, securing freedom for numerous individuals falsely accused of serious crimes.

Pros: The Law Office of James D. Owen, LLC receives widespread acclaim for Attorney Jim Owen’s exceptional legal prowess, unwavering dedication to clients, and compassionate approach that makes clients feel truly cared for. Clients rave about the firm’s professionalism, responsiveness, and ability to achieve favorable outcomes through masterful defense strategies.

Cons: One negative review expressed dissatisfaction with the handling of a specific case.

Palmer Legal Defense

With over 26 years of experience, Stephen E. Palmer is a highly trusted and accomplished Columbus criminal defense attorney known for his distinctive client-centric approach, vast legal expertise spanning from DUIs to complex federal cases, and a proven ability to achieve favorable outcomes through meticulous strategy and leveraging an extensive network of experts. Palmer’s notoriety includes consistent recognition as an Ohio Super Lawyer, prominent media presence providing legal insights, and active involvement in professional legal associations.

Pros: The reviews resoundingly praise Palmer Legal Defense for their exceptional legal representation, professionalism, responsiveness, and caring approach in guiding clients through complex legal matters. Clients laud the attorneys’ brilliant legal strategies, clear communication, and genuine concern for achieving favorable outcomes.

Cons: A few negative reviews lack specific details but express dissatisfaction without elaborating further.

Dominy Law Firm, LLC

The Dominy Law Firm is a boutique criminal defense practice that distinguishes itself through its narrow focus on DUI/OVI offenses, vehicular crimes, and criminal cases, leveraging the extensive experience and expertise of attorney Shawn Dominy and a limited caseload to provide personalized service and achieve favorable outcomes for clients. With a modern, efficient operation, convenient location, and commitment to consistent communication, the firm serves clients throughout central Ohio counties and charges reasonable fees for its high-quality legal representation.

Pros: Dominy Law Firm, LLC garners widespread praise for its professionalism, expertise in handling DUI/OVI cases, responsiveness in keeping clients informed, and achieving favorable outcomes. Clients commend the attorneys’ attention to detail, effective communication, and diligent efforts in fighting for their interests. The positive reviews highlight a firm that supports clients throughout the legal process and consistently delivers satisfactory results.

Cons: One review mentions an unpleasant experience with the support staff, suggesting room for improvement in creating a positive first impression.